Both are bellows-driven free-reed instruments with a Stradella bass system (left hand). The difference is entirely in the right-hand keyboard.
| Feature | Button Accordion (Chromatic/Diatonic) | Piano Accordion |
|---|---|---|
| Right Hand | Rows of buttons (2–5 rows); each button = 1 note (chromatic) or diatonic scale | Piano-style keyboard (2–3+ octaves); 1 key = 1 note |
| Left Hand | Stradella bass system (buttons for chords/bass) | Same Stradella bass system |
| Learning Curve | Requires memorizing button geography; isomorphic patterns (same shape = same interval) | Intuitive for pianists; visual layout = immediate note location |
| Compactness | More notes in smaller space (up to 5+ octaves) | Larger for equivalent range |
| Typical Genres | Folk, polka, tango (bandoneon), Cajun, Norteño, Balkan, classical (bayan) | Classical, jazz, French musette, tango, pop, film music |
Both are "real" accordions. The music matters more than the keyboard.