After drummer Jason Costa departed in 2009, the metalcore band All That Remains made a decisive shift: they adopted programmed drums (drum machine / samples) for both studio recordings and live performances. They have not had a permanent drummer since.
This move sparked debate among fans—some missed the organic feel of a live drummer, while others appreciated the precision and consistency of programmed parts, especially for the band's tightly syncopated, high-tempo material. The decision reflects a broader trend in modern metal where production perfection often trumps live spontaneity.