Yes, You Hear Beats When Piano Keys Are Played Together
Correction: Beats are audible when two piano keys sound simultaneously—provided their frequencies are close enough.
Physics of Beats
- Cause: Interference of two waves with slightly different frequencies.
- Beat frequency: |f₁ – f₂| (Hz).
- Perception: Amplitude modulation—a "wah-wah" pulsing.
Piano Examples
- Unison tuning: Three strings per note; if one detunes by 1 Hz → 1 beat/second.
- Semitone apart: ~16 Hz difference (C4=261.63, C#4=277.18) → too fast for distinct beats (perceived as roughness).
- Perfect fifth (C4+G4): 3:2 ratio → difference tone, not beats.
- Out-of-tune unison: Most common audible beats—creates "honky-tonk" sound.
Tuning Application
- Tuners listen for beats between reference pitch and string.
- Zero beats = in tune.
- Stretch tuning: Octaves tuned slightly wide (2:1 + cents) to compensate for inharmonicity.
Cross-Instrument
Piano + guitar playing the same note → beats reveal tuning mismatch.
Beats are a fundamental psychoacoustic phenomenon—always present with frequency proximity.