Throughout the song, Skylar Grey asks numerous questions, wondering if specific things would have made a difference in the outcome of the relationship. These questions range from asking whether saying "I love you" more often or paying more attention to the other person's needs could have saved the relationship, to if the relationship was destined to fail regardless.
The chorus emphasizes the yearning to know whether any effort or change could have prevented the relationship's downfall: "Would it matter? Would it change a thing?" The repetitive nature of these questions reflects the feeling of being stuck in a cycle of doubt and uncertainty.
The song's lyrics also suggest a sense of nostalgia, with mentions of "old days" and "faded pictures." This reinforces the idea of reminiscing about the past and wondering what could have been different.
Ultimately, "Would It Matter" captures the emotional anguish and introspection that follow a romantic breakup. It conveys the longing for answers and the desire for clarity amidst the confusion and turmoil of a relationship's end. The song speaks to the human experience of seeking closure and understanding after a significant loss.