Here's a breakdown of the key differences:
PS3/Xbox 360 (2008) version:
* Pros:
* More polished graphics and lighting.
* Generally considered to have the superior level design, particularly in the Werehog stages.
* Features a day/night cycle that adds a unique element to gameplay.
* Contains the original soundtrack, which is generally preferred by fans.
* Cons:
* Some technical issues, such as frame rate drops, can occur in some areas.
* The game may run slower on certain hardware.
* The Werehog gameplay is generally considered to be more difficult and clunky.
Wii/PS2/PSP version (2008):
* Pros:
* Easier to run on older hardware.
* More streamlined gameplay, with a greater focus on speed and momentum.
* The Werehog gameplay is generally considered to be more accessible and fun.
* Features simplified visuals and a different soundtrack that some players prefer.
* Cons:
* Less detailed graphics.
* Simpler level design, particularly in the Werehog stages.
* Less polished overall.
Ultimately, the best version for you depends on:
* Hardware: If you have a powerful PC or console, the PS3/Xbox 360 version might be a better choice. However, if you're playing on older hardware, the Wii/PS2/PSP version might be a better option.
* Gameplay style: If you prefer fast-paced, streamlined gameplay, the Wii/PS2/PSP version might be a better fit. If you enjoy more challenging and strategic gameplay, the PS3/Xbox 360 version might be better.
* Visuals and soundtrack: If you prioritize visual fidelity and the original soundtrack, the PS3/Xbox 360 version is the way to go. If you're more drawn to the simpler visual style and different soundtrack, the Wii/PS2/PSP version might be more appealing.
Recommendation:
* For hardcore Sonic fans and those with powerful hardware, the PS3/Xbox 360 version is the recommended choice.
* For players with older hardware or those who prefer a more streamlined experience, the Wii/PS2/PSP version is a viable alternative.
It's also worth checking out some gameplay videos or reviews of both versions to get a better sense of which one you might prefer.