Arts >> Music >> Live Music

Who Sang "Without You"? The Harry Nilsson vs. Badfinger Story

Two Definitive Versions

The song "Without You" is most famously associated with Harry Nilsson, whose 1971 version (from Nilsson Schmilsson) became a global #1 hit.

But It Wasn't His Song Originally

Badfinger—the British rock band—wrote and recorded it first in 1969 for Magic Christian Music. Composers: Pete Ham and Tom Evans.

Other Notable Covers

Legacy

Both Nilsson's and Badfinger's versions are celebrated for emotional intensity and melodic beauty. Tragically, Ham and Evans both died by suicide, partly due to royalties disputes over this song—a somber footnote to a masterpiece.

Live Music

Related Categories