1. Popularity and Commercial Success:
- Three Doors Down: The band has sold over 16 million albums worldwide, with multiple charting singles such as "Kryptonite," "Here Without You," and "When I'm Gone." They have achieved mainstream success and gained significant popularity in the rock genre.
- Smash Mouth: Smash Mouth gained prominence in the late '90s with their hit songs "Walkin' on the Sun" and "All Star," which became cultural phenomena and were featured in popular movies. They achieved commercial success and widespread recognition for their unique blend of rock, ska, and pop music.
2. Longevity and Consistency:
- Three Doors Down: The band has been active since the late '90s and has consistently released albums throughout their career. They have maintained a solid fan base and continue to tour and perform.
- Smash Mouth: Smash Mouth experienced their peak popularity in the late '90s and early 2000s, but their subsequent releases didn't garner the same level of success. They went on hiatus in 2008 but reunited in 2010 and have continued to perform.
3. Genre and Musical Style:
- Three Doors Down: Their music primarily falls under the rock genre, with a blend of post-grunge, hard rock, and alternative rock elements. They are known for their powerful vocals, catchy melodies, and emotionally driven songs.
- Smash Mouth: Smash Mouth's music is characterized by a fusion of rock, ska, and pop elements, creating an upbeat, energetic sound. Their songs are often infused with catchy hooks, playful lyrics, and a blend of humorous and introspective themes.
4. Critical Acclaim and Legacy:
- Three Doors Down: While they have achieved commercial success, Three Doors Down has generally received mixed critical reviews. Their music has been praised for its emotional depth and accessibility, but also criticized for its perceived formulaic nature.
- Smash Mouth: Smash Mouth's early success was met with both praise and criticism. Their hits "Walkin' on the Sun" and "All Star" became pop culture anthems, but their subsequent work received mixed reviews, with some critics finding their music to be repetitive or lacking in substance.
Ultimately, the choice of which band is better is subjective and dependent on individual preferences for musical styles and the criteria they value in a band. Both Three Doors Down and Smash Mouth have left their mark on the music industry, albeit in different ways, and continue to have their own dedicated fan bases.