No consensus exists. "Biggest" depends entirely on the metric:
Eminem – 220M+ worldwide (highest-selling rapper).
Jay-Z – 23 wins (most for a rapper). Kendrick Lamar – 13. Eminem – 15.
Tupac Shakur – Enduring icon, poetic activism, posthumous influence.
The Notorious B.I.G. – Lyrical mastery, East Coast definition.
Jay-Z – Cited by Kendrick, Drake, Cole, etc.
Eminem – Technical benchmark, mainstream breakthrough.
Drake – Streaming records, chart longevity.
Kendrick Lamar – Critical acclaim, Pulitzer (2018).
All are valid lenses. The debate reflects what we value: sales, awards, cultural footprint, lyrical skill, longevity, innovation.