Worst-Rated Smallville Season: Season 4 (2004–2005)
Season 4 (2004–2005) is the lowest-rated season of Smallville.
Ratings
- IMDb average: 6.7/10 (vs. series avg. 7.7).
- Rotten Tomatoes audience: 68% (vs. 80%+ for S1–3, 5, 7–10).
- TV.com (historical): Lowest user scores.
Common Criticisms
- Lois Lane introduction (Erica Durance) – initially divisive; chemistry took time.
- Lana-centric arcs: Witchcraft, possession, death fake-outs – repetitive.
- Villain of week: More procedural; less mythology.
- Lex/Clark tension: Stalled; "will they/won't they" fatigue.
- Magic/occult elements: Isobel, Brianna, Margaret – felt tonally off.
Defenders Note
- Introduced key Lois/Chloe dynamic.
- Jensen Ackles (Jason Teague) – standout guest arc.
- "Sacred" (S4E20) – series-high emotional episode.
- Sets up S5's stronger arc (Zod, Brainiac, Fine).
Series Context
All 10 seasons range 7.0–8.5 IMDb. Season 4 is a relative dip, not a "bad" season. The show's consistency is notable for a 218-episode run.