Did Victorians Like Sherlock Holmes? Mostly Yes, But Opinions Varied
Definitive polling didn't exist, but evidence suggests:
Evidence They Liked Him
- Immense popularity: Stories published in magazines/newspapers, sold in vast quantities.
- Critical acclaim: Critics praised clever plots, intricate deductions, vivid characters.
- Cultural impact: Holmes became phenomenon—influencing fashion, language, iconic deerstalker/pipe look.
- Adaptations: Numerous plays and early films solidified popularity.
Evidence Some Disliked Him
- Skepticism about deduction: Some scientists saw methods as intuition/luck over scientific reasoning.
- Morality concerns: Holmes often operated outside law, could seem manipulative.
- Gender roles: Some female critics found his cold detachment unappealing vs. romantic heroes.
Overall
Large Victorian segments enjoyed Holmes—stories captured public imagination. But opinions varied: some loved him, some disliked him, many in between.