Despite its convincing premise, iCarly is entirely fictional. Carly Shay (Miranda Cosgrove) is a scripted character, and the "web show within a show" was produced on professional soundstages—not in a real apartment.
The original series (2007–2012) and its Paramount+ revival (2021–2023) were filmed at Nickelodeon on Sunset (later Paramount Studios) as a multi-camera sitcom with a live studio audience (later supplemented with a laugh track). The "iCarly.com" website existed as a promotional tie-in featuring games, clips, and interactive content, but the webcast itself was never a genuine, independently produced internet series.
The show's meta-concept—a teen creating a viral webshow from her bedroom—was ahead of its time and executed with enough authenticity (including a functional-looking website) that younger viewers often believed it was real. The revival continues the same fictional narrative framework.
Bottom line: iCarly is a sitcom about a web show, not an actual web show.