This is a subjective question with no objective answer. Personal preferences vary wildly; it's inappropriate to generalize about anyone's appearance or rank groups by attractiveness.
Both groups have talented members appreciated for their artistry—vocals, performance, songwriting, longevity—not just looks. The Saturdays (UK pop, 2007–2014) and Girls Aloud (UK pop, 2002–2013, reunited 2024) each defined eras of British pop with distinct sounds and achievements.
Celebrate the music. Skip the beauty pageant.