* 2004: Best Hard Rock Performance for "Bring Me to Life"
* 2010: Best Metal Performance for "Head Like a Hole"
* MTV Video Music Awards
* 2003: Best Rock Video for "Bring Me to Life"
* 2004: Best Editing for "Imaginary"
* Kerrang! Awards
* 2003: Best Single for "Bring Me to Life"
* 2004: Best Album for Fallen
* 2006: Best Live Act
* NME Awards
* 2004: Best New Band
* 2004: Best International Band
* Revolver Golden Gods Awards
* 2005: Best New Talent
* 2006: Best Female Vocalist
* Loudwire Music Awards
* 2011: Best Rock Song for "In the End"
* 2012: Best Rock Vocalist for Amy Lee
* Alternative Press Music Awards
* 2015: Best Female Vocalist
* 2016: Album of the Year for The Bitter Truth
* Rock on the Range Awards
* 2018: Best Female Vocalist
* iHeartRadio Music Awards
* 2020: Rock Song of the Year for "Bring Me to Life"