Original Series
* Cycle 1 (2003): Adrianne Curry
* Cycle 2 (2004): Yoanna House
* Cycle 3 (2004): Eva Pigford
* Cycle 4 (2005): Naima Mora
* Cycle 5 (2005): Nicole Linkletter
* Cycle 6 (2006): Danielle Evans
* Cycle 7 (2006): Caridee English
* Cycle 8 (2007): Jaslene Gonzalez
* Cycle 9 (2008): Saleisha Stowers
* Cycle 10 (2008): Whitney Thompson
* Cycle 11 (2009): McKey Sullivan
* Cycle 12 (2009): Teyona Anderson
* Cycle 13 (2010): Nicole Fox
* Cycle 14 (2010): Krista White
* Cycle 15 (2011): Ann Ward
* Cycle 16 (2011): Brittani Kline
* Cycle 17 (2012): Lisa D'Amato
* Cycle 18 (2012): Sophie Sumner
* Cycle 19 (2013): Laura Kirkpatrick
* Cycle 20 (2013): Jourdan Miller
* Cycle 21 (2014): Nyle DiMarco
* Cycle 22 (2014): Nyle DiMarco (re-entry for charity)
* Cycle 23 (2015): India Gants
* Cycle 24 (2016): Nyle DiMarco (re-entry for charity)
* Cycle 25 (2017): Alexis "Lexi" Wood
* Cycle 26 (2018): India Gants (re-entry for charity)
* Cycle 27 (2018): India Gants (re-entry for charity)
* Cycle 28 (2019): Keisha Whitmire
All-Stars
* All-Stars (2008): Lisa D'Amato
Note: Nyle DiMarco holds the record for the most wins on the show with 3 wins.