Arts >> Magic >> Magic Tricks

Ismene's Counsel in Antigone: Pragmatism vs. Principle

In Sophocles' Antigone, Ismene's opening argument (lines 54–77) urges her sister against burying Polyneices. Her reasoning is pragmatic, not principled:

Arguments

  1. Legal reality: Creon's edict carries death penalty. "We must obey... the powers that be."
  2. Gendered vulnerability: "We are women... not born to contend with men." Ismene accepts patriarchal limits as immutable.
  3. Family extinction: Father, mother, brothers dead. "If we transgress... our death will be more shameful." She fears total erasure of their line.
  4. Futility: One burial changes nothing politically. The dead cannot thank them.

Contrast with Antigone

Ismene represents phronesis (practical wisdom); Antigone represents arete (moral excellence). Ismene survives; Antigone dies. The play does not fully endorse either—it stages the collision.

Later Shift

After Antigone's arrest, Ismene offers to share guilt: "I did it too." Antigone refuses: "Justice will not allow you." Ismene's love ultimately exceeds her caution.

Magic Tricks

Related Categories