1. Have a 100% Superstar rating. Superstar ratings are displayed when the player is highlighted on the menu screen at the beginning of the game session or can be viewed under the "MyPlayer" tab.
2. Record 100 sacks throughout your Madden career.
3. Make the Pro Bowl 3 consecutive times.
4. Retire your player without being traded or cut by your team.
For Ring 4:
1. Have a 100% Superstar rating.
2. Record 200 sacks throughout your Madden career.
3. Make the Pro Bowl 5 times.
4. Win 3 Super Bowls.
5. Retire your player without being traded or cut by your team.