Restarting Pokémon Platinum Won't Bring Back Event Pokémon—Here's Why
No. Restarting Pokémon Platinum erases your save file, but it does not restore access to special event distributions like:
- Member Card → Darkrai (Newmoon Island)
- Oak's Letter → Shaymin (Flower Paradise)
- Azure Flute → Arceus (Hall of Origin)
Why They're Gone Forever
These were one-time, real-world distributions via Nintendo Wi-Fi Connection or local wireless (2009–2010). The servers are dead. The event flags live on Nintendo's infrastructure, not your cartridge. A new save file has no way to trigger them.
Current Legitimate Options
- Trade from someone who received the event originally.
- Transfer via Pokémon Bank/Home from another game (e.g., HeartGold/SoulSilver, or Gen V+).
- Homebrew/Hacks: Custom firmware can inject events—but this flags saves as illegitimate for online play.
If you missed the 2009–2010 window, you missed it. No soft reset, no new game, no in-game action changes that.