Do Narnia, Bedknobs, Mary Poppins, or The Witches Portray Magic as Anti-Religious?
No. Each work treats magic through its author's moral lens, none condemning religion:
- Narnia (C.S. Lewis) – Magic serves Aslan, a Christ-figure; "Deep Magic" is divine law. Faith transcends sorcery.
- Mary Poppins – Whimsical, benevolent magic; no theological conflict.
- Bedknobs & Broomsticks – Lighthearted witchcraft used against Nazis; villains are fascists, not magic.
- The Witches (Roald Dahl) – Witches are evil beings; magic itself is a neutral tool the boy uses to defeat them.
Lewis wrote from Christian conviction; Dahl from secular humanism. Neither frames magic as inherently anti-religious.