Setup: Two doors (heaven/hell), two guards (one always lies, one always tells truth). You don't know which guard is which or which door is which. One question to one guard.
Ask either guard: "If I asked the other guard which door leads to heaven, what would he say?"
| Guard Asked | Other Guard Would Say | Answer Given | True Door |
|---|---|---|---|
| Truth-teller | Hell (lie) | Hell (truth about lie) | Heaven = other door |
| Liar | Heaven (truth) | Hell (lie about truth) | Heaven = other door |
Result: Both guards point to hell. Choose the opposite door.
The question creates a double negation (truth about lie = lie; lie about truth = lie) or double affirmation, collapsing the uncertainty into a reliable signal regardless of guard identity.