Evaluating the Act 4 Accusations in The Crucible: Why They're False
The accusations at the end of Act 4 should not be accepted at face value. Reasons for doubt:
- Abigail Williams is the primary accuser – Established liar; motive: eliminate Elizabeth Proctor to have John.
- Accused are pillars of the community – Rebecca Nurse, Martha Corey, etc. No prior evidence of witchcraft.
- Accusers' behavior is suspect – Trance states, "spectral evidence," possible mass psychogenic illness or manipulation.
- Judicial process is corrupt – Danforth prioritizes court's authority over truth.
Miller intends the audience to see the accusations as false, politically motivated, and hysteria-driven.