Yu-Gi-Oh Ruling: Ultimate Obedient Fiend vs. Utopia & Zenmaines
No. Ultimate Obedient Fiend cannot negate the effects of Number 39: Utopia or Wind-Up Zenmaines. Here's the precise ruling.
The Card Text
Ultimate Obedient Fiend negates effects of Level 5 or higher monsters during the Battle Phase / Damage Step—only while it is also Level 5 or higher.
The Targets
- Number 39: Utopia – Rank 4 (Xyz Monsters have Rank, not Level; treated as Level 0 for Level-based conditions)
- Wind-Up Zenmaines – Rank 3
Why It Fails
- Xyz Monsters have Ranks, not Levels
- For Level-based conditions, Xyz Monsters are treated as Level 0
- Both Utopia (Rank 4) and Zenmaines (Rank 3) are below Level 5
- Therefore, Ultimate Obedient Fiend's condition ("while it is Level 5+") is met, but the targets don't meet the "Level 5+" requirement
Key Distinction
This isn't about ATK/DEF or battle position. It's a hard mechanical check: Is the target monster Level 5 or higher? For Xyz Monsters, the answer is always no (Level 0).
What Would Work
- Cards negating Rank 4+ or Xyz Monster effects specifically
- Cards negating monster effects regardless of Level/Rank (e.g., Infinite Impermanence, Forbidden Droplet)
Level/Rank distinction is one of Yu-Gi-Oh's most tested rules. Master it, and you'll never fall for this interaction again.