Common misremembering. In Season 2's "You Heart NY" (Ep. 18), Big and Carrie do not dance together. Their first significant shared dance happens in Season 4, Episode 18: "I Heart NY" (Miranda's wedding)—to Fleetwood Mac's "Landslide."
Carrie's maid of honor; Big's best man. The reception slow dance crackles with unresolved history. Stevie Nicks' lyrics—"Can I sail through the changing ocean tides?"—mirror their decade-long orbit. No grand gesture. Just two people holding on, aware the song will end.
Season 2 had tension. Season 4 had Landslide.