Build a small snowman; place a note in its hands: “Winter formal with me? — [Your Name], [Date].” Let her discover it.
Place a note inside a snowball: “Winter formal?” or “Snow much fun with me?” Put snowball in a box with candy/gift; hand to her.
Serve hot chocolate with marshmallows/whipped cream. Attach sealed envelope to cup: “Will you go to winter formal with me?”
Personalize to her interests for a memorable “Yes!”