Gone with the Wind: Melanie Wore Mourning, Not Scarlett
Correcting a Common Misremembering
Scarlett O'Hara (Vivien Leigh) does not go into mourning in Gone with the Wind. It's Melanie Wilkes (Olivia de Havilland) who dons black crepe and veil—mourning her husband Ashley Wilkes, presumed dead after the Battle of Gettysburg (he survives, captured).
Why the Confusion?
- Scarlett wears black for her first husband Charles Hamilton's funeral (early film)—but that's conventional widow's weeds, not the deep, prolonged mourning Melanie adopts.
- Scarlett's infamous "I'll never be hungry again" scene shows her in a dress made from green velvet curtains—not mourning attire.
- Melanie's quiet, prolonged grief contrasts with Scarlett's performative survivalism—a deliberate character foil.
Mourning Customs in the Film
The film accurately depicts Victorian mourning stages: deep black (first year), second mourning (black with white trim), half-mourning (gray, lavender, white). Melanie progresses through them; Scarlett weaponizes fashion.
Next rewatch: watch Melanie. Her mourning is the film's moral anchor.