What Makes a Poem American Literature? Three Qualifying Paths
A poem qualifies as American literature through any of three primary criteria:
- Subject Matter: American themes, settings, history, geography, culture, or people.
- Style: Forms prevalent in American poetic tradition (e.g., free verse, Whitmanian catalogues, Objectivist precision) vs. inherited European forms (e.g., strict sonnets, Spenserians).
- Author's Nationality: Poems by American authors, regardless of subject or style.
Examples Across the Spectrum
- "The Star-Spangled Banner" – Francis Scott Key (subject + author)
- "I Hear America Singing" – Walt Whitman (subject + style + author)
- "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening" – Robert Frost (subject + author; form is European but voice is American)
- "The Waste Land" – T.S. Eliot (author; subject/style transatlantic)
- "Howl" – Allen Ginsberg (style + subject + author)
- "The Colossus" – Sylvia Plath (author; subject/style complex)
- "Citizen: An American Lyric" – Claudia Rankine (subject + style + author)
These poems vary wildly in form, topic, and era—but each qualifies through at least one of the three pathways. American literature is a big tent; the only requirement is a genuine connection to the American project, broadly conceived.