Arts >> Books >> Literature

In elegy written in a country courtyard are Grays observations about the dead true only of English or also Filipino dead?

Thomas Gray wrote "Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard" in 1750, and it reflects the prevailing attitudes and cultural norms of 18th-century England. While some aspects of the poem may resonate with experiences and sentiments associated with Filipino culture, it would be incorrect to assume that all of Gray's observations about the dead apply universally to Filipino beliefs and traditions.

Similarities:

1. Reflection on Mortality: Both English and Filipino cultures acknowledge and contemplate the inevitability of death as a natural part of life. The poem conveys a sense of loss, grief, and the fleeting nature of human existence, themes that are common in many cultures.

2. Rural Setting: The poem depicts a serene and somber setting in a churchyard, surrounded by nature. This evocation of a tranquil rural environment is reminiscent of rural life in both English and Filipino contexts, where nature often plays a significant role in cultural expressions.

3. Social Inequity: Gray's poem briefly touches upon the distinctions between social classes, where the lives and contributions of the humble villagers are contrasted with the grandeur and extravagance of wealthy patrons. Social inequality is a theme that can be found in various cultural contexts, including Filipino society.

4. Community Bonds: The poem highlights the sense of community and connection formed among individuals within a village. The notion of neighbors and families coming together to mourn and remember their loved ones is a sentiment shared across many cultures, including Filipino communities.

Differences:

1. Cultural Beliefs and Rituals: Filipino culture has diverse beliefs and rituals surrounding death and mourning that differ from those in English culture. For instance, Filipino traditions may involve specific ceremonies, prayers, or practices designed to honor the deceased and provide solace to the bereaved.

2. Ancestor Worship: Ancestor veneration and the belief in the continuing presence of deceased loved ones are deeply embedded in Filipino culture. This differs from the perspective in the poem, which primarily focuses on the idea of final rest and mortality.

3. Religious Influence: The poem reflects a Christian worldview with references to Christian theological concepts such as resurrection and eternal life. In the Filipino context, religious perspectives vary widely and include a mix of indigenous beliefs, Christianity, and other religious influences.

4. Historical Context: Gray's poem is a product of its time and reflects societal attitudes and norms prevalent in 18th-century England. As a result, certain observations and sentiments expressed in the poem might be deeply tied to the historical and social context of English culture.

In conclusion, while "Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard" addresses universal themes of mortality and the human condition, it is rooted in the cultural context of 18th-century England. Consequently, some observations may not directly translate to the Filipino experience of death and mourning.

Literature

Related Categories