Arts >> Books >> Literature

Defining the American Identity: First Impressions of Crèvecœur's "What Is an American?"

Published in 1782 as part of Letters from an American Farmer (Letter III), J. Hector St. John de Crèvecœur's essay offers a foundational perspective on the emerging American identity through the lens of a French immigrant. The piece remains a touchstone for understanding the mythos of the American Dream, even as modern readers recognize its significant blind spots.

The Optimistic Vision: America as a Land of Reinvention

Crèvecœur presents America as a place where the oppressed and downtrodden of Europe can shed their past identities and forge new lives through labor and liberty. This vision of boundless opportunity—where "man is free" and industry is rewarded—became a powerful narrative that continues to shape national self-perception. The essay celebrates the transformative potential of a society unburdened by rigid class hierarchies, offering a compelling portrait of individual agency.

Celebration of Diversity: The Melting Pot Ideal

One of the essay's most enduring contributions is its articulation of the "melting pot" concept. Crèvecœur observes how immigrants from diverse European nations—English, Scottish, Irish, French, Dutch, Germans, and Swedes—blend into "a new race of men." He frames this amalgamation as a source of national vigor, creating a people whose mixed heritage fuels enterprise and resilience. This early celebration of pluralism anticipates core themes of American identity.

Individualism and Self-Reliance

The "American" in Crèvecœur's telling is enterprising, independent, and defined by self-reliance. The essay elevates the yeoman farmer as the archetypal citizen—someone who works his own land, answers to no lord, and builds his future through sweat and ingenuity. This agrarian individualism becomes a cornerstone of the national character, influencing everything from political philosophy to cultural mythology.

Nuanced and Dated Aspects: The Gaps in the Narrative

For all its influence, the essay suffers from profound omissions. Its romantic idealism glosses over the brutal realities of chattel slavery, the violent displacement of Indigenous peoples, and entrenched inequalities of gender and class. The agrarian bias equates authentic American identity with farming life, marginalizing urban commerce, maritime trade, and the diverse economic realities of the early republic. Perhaps most critically, the perspective is exclusively that of a European immigrant; the voices of the enslaved, Native nations, and women are entirely absent.

Legacy: A Foundational but Incomplete Text

Crèvecœur's essay articulates the aspirational mythos of the American Dream with remarkable power. It captures the optimism, diversity, and individualism that would become central to national identity. Yet its silences are as instructive as its proclamations. Reading it today requires holding two truths: that it helped define a nation's self-image, and that its definition was partial, exclusionary, and in need of constant revision. The essay remains essential not because it tells the whole story, but because it reveals how the story began—and what was left out.

Literature

Related Categories