Key Themes in Thomas More and Erasmus: Reform, Classics, Reason
Both Renaissance humanists advocated for:
1. Church Reform (from Within)
- Erasmus (Praise of Folly, 1511; Novum Testamentum, 1516): Satirized clerical corruption, scholastic sterility; urged return to ad fontes (Scripture & Church Fathers) in original languages.
- More (Utopia, 1516; Dialogue Concerning Heresies, 1529): Imagined a society with religious tolerance, communal property, rational laws; defended Catholic unity but demanded moral clergy.
2. Revival of Classical Learning
- Both mastered Greek/Latin; edited/published classical texts (Erasmus: Aristotle, Church Fathers; More: Lucian translations).
- Believed humanitas (cultivation through classics) produced virtuous citizens.
3. Reason, Education & Social Justice
- Utopia: No private property, 6-hour workday, free hospitals, religious pluralism—radical for 1516.
- Erasmus: Education of a Christian Prince (1516) – ruler as servant, educated in classics & Scripture.
Divergence
Erasmus stayed Catholic, critiquing Luther’s schism. More died a martyr for papal supremacy (1535). Their shared humanism fractured over authority.