Sanford Dole, the Missionaries, and the 1893 Overthrow of the Hawaiian Monarchy
A Coup Disguised as a Revolution
On January 17, 1893, a coalition of American and European businessmen, backed by U.S. Marines, overthrew the sovereign Hawaiian Kingdom. Sanford B. Dole—a Hawaii-born lawyer, judge, and leader of the Committee of Safety—became the first President of the puppet Republic of Hawaii. Missionaries and their descendants played complex, pivotal roles.
The Committee of Safety's Motive
Queen Liliʻuokalani's proposed constitution would have restored monarchical power and limited foreign influence—threatening the economic dominance of the "sugar barons" and their political allies.
The Overthrow Mechanics
- Jan 16: U.S.S. Boston lands 162 Marines "to protect American lives and property."
- Jan 17: Committee declares Provisional Government; Queen yields under protest to avoid bloodshed, appealing to U.S. President Cleveland.
- July 1894: Republic of Hawaii proclaimed; Dole elected president.
Roles of Dole and the Missionaries
- Sanford Dole: Architect of the coup, first President, relentless annexation advocate. Later became first Territorial Governor (1900).
- Missionaries (ABCFM): Since 1820, they'd shaped Hawaiian society—schools, churches, written language, Western law. Divided loyalties: Some (like the Thurston, Castle, Cooke families) were Committee leaders. Others (e.g., Reverend Sereno Bishop) opposed the overthrow as unjust. The missionary legacy is not monolithic.
Legacy: A Contested History
The 1893 overthrow is recognized by the U.S. (Apology Resolution, 1993) as an illegal act violating treaties and sovereignty. It remains a flashpoint in Hawaiian independence movements and debates over reparations, federal recognition, and historical truth.