Arts >> Books >> Fiction

Hawthorne's "Utopia" in The Scarlet Letter: Irony, Not Praise

Hawthorne never calls the Puritan colony a "utopia" sincerely.

In The Scarlet Letter, the Massachusetts Bay Colony is depicted as:

If Hawthorne uses "utopia," it's ironic — contrasting the colony's self-image as a "city upon a hill" (Winthrop's sermon) with its reality as a place of secrecy, judgment, and suppressed humanity.

The forest, not the settlement, represents freedom — making the colony a dystopia in practice.

Fiction

Related Categories