Mary Shelley's 1831 Intro: Polite Jab at Percy's Ghost Story
Mary Shelley never explicitly says Percy is bad at ghost stories. Instead, in the 1831 Introduction to Frankenstein:
- Shared Challenge: Notes the group (Byron, Percy, her, Polidori) agreed to write a ghost story.
- Collective Failure: Calls their initial efforts "dreadful" and "too horrible"—relying on clichéd specters.
- Her Innovation: Proposes a "new" idea: a being created by science, not supernatural haunting.
- Implicit Contrast: Elevates her concept without naming Percy's specific attempt.
It's a diplomatic literary critique: the genre was stale, her approach was fresh.