Nothing inherently "bad"—it's a magical Disney palace. But practically speaking:
These "flaws" are narrative features: isolation mirrors Ariel's separation from her world; the cliff embodies the land/sea divide. Architecturally, it's a fantasy—not a zoning plan.
Subjective verdict: charmingly impractical, perfectly symbolic. The castle's design serves the story's themes of separation and longing, not real-world livability.