"Turkey" on Broadway: When a Show Flops Spectacularly
In Broadway slang, a “turkey” is a production that fails both commercially and critically—closing quickly, often within weeks or even days, after scathing reviews and empty houses.
Hallmarks of a Turkey
- Short run: Under 100 performances; many close after fewer than 30.
- Negative critical consensus: Reviews are uniformly harsh.
- Financial loss: Investors lose their money.
- Afterlife: Some become cautionary tales; others gain cult “camp” followings.
Infamous Turkeys
- Moose Murders (1983) – Closed after a single performance.
- Carrie (1988) – $8 million loss, 5 performances.
- Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark (2011) – Record $75 million cost, injuries, delays; ran 3 years only after a massive overhaul.
- Rebecca (2012) – Never opened; financing collapsed.
Etymology
The term likely stems from 1920s show-biz slang where “turkey” meant a failure—possibly from the bird’s perceived stupidity or the “cold turkey” withdrawal metaphor. The opposite is a “smash hit” or “blockbuster.”