Macbeth vs. Banquo: Contrasting Reactions to the Supernatural and Power
Shakespeare constructs Banquo as Macbeth's moral foil. Both hear the Witches' prophecies; both face temptation. Their divergent responses illuminate the play's central theme: character is destiny.
Witnessing the Three Witches
- Macbeth: Sees opportunity. "Glamis, and Thane of Cawdor: / The greatest is behind." Ambition ignites instantly.
- Banquo: Responds with skepticism. "The instruments of darkness tell us truths, / Win us with honest trifles, to betray's / In deepest consequence." He warns against the bait.
Hearing of Duncan's Murder
- Macbeth: Spirals into guilt, hallucination (the dagger), and performative outrage.
- Banquo: Suspects Macbeth immediately ("Thou play'dst most foully for't") but acts cautiously, prioritizing survival and moral witness.
Learning of Fleance's Escape
- Macbeth: Panic. "Then comes my fit again." Orders the child's death—tyranny consolidating.
- Banquo: Dead, but his ghost embodies the moral order Macbeth violates. Fleance's survival = hope for legitimate lineage.
Facing the Ghost of Banquo
- Macbeth: Public collapse. "Avaunt! and quit my sight!" The ghost is his conscience externalized.
- Banquo: Silent, seated, unshaken—his presence alone indicts.
Confronting Macduff
- Macbeth: False bravado ("I bear a charmed life") crumbling to nihilistic despair ("Tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow").
- Banquo: Absent in body, but his son's line (James I's ancestry) is the political future Macbeth cannot stop.
Overall Contrast
Macbeth reacts with escalating emotional turmoil, paranoia, and ruthless power-seeking. Banquo responds with caution, skepticism, and moral integrity. The play posits that faced with the same supernatural prompt, choice—not fate—determines the man.