After Johnny kills Bob Sheldon in self-defense, the two Greasers flee to an abandoned church in Windrixville. To avoid recognition, they undertake a drastic physical transformation—one that symbolizes their shedding of identity.
The haircut is especially poignant. For Greasers, hair is identity. Ponyboy narrates, "It was my pride. It was long and silky, just like Soda's only a little redder." Shearing it off marks their exile from their world. The shoe polish, applied with trembling hands, underscores their youth and desperation.
The disguise works—briefly. But it cannot hide them from the fire that later engulfs the church, nor from the choices that follow. The physical alteration mirrors their internal unmooring: no longer Tulsa Greasers, not yet heroes, just two boys running from a death they didn't choose.