The Esophagor doesn't *ask* for pumpkin pie in Neopets. He's a villain who kidnaps Neopets and forces them to eat him! He's a giant, sentient, talking esophagus with an insatiable appetite—a major antagonist appearing in several storylines.
You might be mixing him up with another character. Possibly a side quest or story where someone requests pumpkin pie?
Share more context about where you encountered this idea—we can identify the correct character!