Did Macbeth Kill the King's Guards Before or After Duncan's Murder? After—As Cover-Up
He killed them after—not before. The sequence in 2.3:
- Macduff and Lennox discover Duncan's murdered body.
- The two guards are found drugged and bloody (framed by Lady Macbeth).
- Macbeth kills them in a rage — "O, yet I do repent me of my fury, / That I did kill them" (2.3.103–104).
- He claims he punished the "murderers." Actually, he silenced witnesses.
Why the Timing Matters
- Before: Would alert the castle. Impossible to frame guards if they're dead before discovery.
- After: Positions him as righteous avenger. Eliminates the only living witnesses to the framing.
- Lady Macbeth's plan: Drug guards → Macbeth kills Duncan → Plant daggers → Macbeth kills guards "in rage." The guards' deaths were always part of the script.
So: Macbeth kills the guards, but as cover-up, not as part of the regicide itself.