Defoe places Crusoe's island with surprising geographic specificity: a remote, uninhabited island near Trinidad, off the coast of Venezuela, in the Caribbean Sea.
Crusoe's voyage from Brazil to Africa is diverted by storms; he wrecks at latitude 9°22' N, placing him near the mouth of the Orinoco River. The island's flora (cocoa, tobacco, citrus), fauna (goats, parrots, turtles), and climate (tropical, rainy/dry seasons) match the southern Caribbean.
Alexander Selkirk was marooned on Más a Tierra (now Robinson Crusoe Island) in the Juan Fernández archipelago, 670 km off Chile—not the Caribbean. Defoe relocated the setting for narrative convenience: proximity to Spanish trade routes, cannibal raids from the mainland, and familiar tropical imagery for English readers.
The island becomes a microcosm of empire—Crusoe imposes English agriculture, religion, and order on a "wild" space, mirroring the colonial project writ small.