The answer is clear: London's West End predates Broadway by roughly two centuries.
London's theatre district traces its origins to the 17th century. The Theatre Royal Drury Lane, the West End's oldest surviving venue, opened its doors in 1663—just a few decades after Shakespeare's death. By the 18th century, the area around Covent Garden and the Strand was already a established theatrical hub.
New York's Broadway, by contrast, didn't develop as a dedicated theatre district until the mid-19th century. The first purpose-built theatres appeared in the 1850s, and the "Great White Way" earned its nickname only after electrification in the 1890s.
This timeline gives the West End a massive historical lead. When Broadway was finding its feet, London had already centuries of theatrical tradition, a deep pool of acting talent, and a repertoire that included the premieres of Sheridan, Wilde, and Gilbert & Sullivan.
Today, both districts are global powerhouses, but the West End's seniority is a matter of historical record.