Cast of "Amish Grace" (2010) – Verified Credits
Amish Grace (2010, Lifetime Movie Network) – dramatization of the 2006 Nickel Mines school shooting.
Actual Credited Cast (IMDb Verified)
- Kimberly Williams-Paisley – Ida Graber (mother of slain girl)
- Michael Kelly – John Stoltzfus (father)
- Alison Pill – Irene Graber (teacher)
- Michael O'Keefe – Preacher
- Brian F. O'Byrne – Sheriff
- J. Smith-Cameron – Sarah Stoltzfus
- John Costelloe – Abe Miller
- Cassandra Hegarty – Mary Stoltzfus
- Alexander Gould – Daniel Stoltzfus
Note: Previous answers incorrectly listed Matt Damon, Katie Holmes, Kevin Kline, William Devane, Meredith Baxter, Sarah Paulson, and Philip Baker Hall—none appear in this film.