The misfit doll in Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer (1964) is named Charlie in the Box (sometimes called "Dolly" or "The Doll").
Her "defect": A broken spring inside her box prevents her from popping up properly—she's a jack-in-the-box that won't "jack." She considers herself a "misfit" because she can't perform her designed function.
On the Island of Misfit Toys, she's alongside the Spotted Elephant, Water Pistol that shoots jelly, Cowboy on an Ostrich, etc. She's delivered to a loving home in the ending credits.