The "Mean" Elf in Rudolph: It's Hermey — And He's Not Actually Mean
The elf often perceived as "mean" or antagonistic in the 1964 Rankin/Bass special Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer is Hermey (voiced by Paul Soles). But "mean" is the wrong word.
Why He Seems Antagonistic
- Nonconformity: Hermey refuses to make toys, insisting he wants to be a dentist.
- Conflict with Foreman: The Elf Foreman berates him: "You're an elf! Elves make toys!" Hermey's defiance reads as insubordination.
- Social Isolation: Other elves mock him ("Hermey doesn't like to make toys!"). He runs away.
Actual Characterization
- Not malicious: Hermey is misunderstood and marginalized, not cruel. His "meanness" is frustration at being forced into a role that doesn't fit.
- Heroic arc: He partners with Rudolph and Yukon Cornelius; uses dental skills to defeat the Abominable Snow Monster (pulls its teeth).
- Resolution: Foreman accepts him; he opens a dental practice at the North Pole.
Other Antagonistic Figures
- Elf Foreman: Represents rigid conformity; pressures Hermey.
- Comet (coach): Excludes Rudolph from games — more directly "mean" to Rudolph.
- Santa (initially): Dismisses Rudolph's nose; later redeems.
Conclusion: Hermey is the "odd elf out" — his perceived meanness is actually autonomy and resilience. He becomes a hero. The special's message: the "misfit" saves the day.