Nothing physically. Dolly is a sweet, kind-hearted doll on the Island of Misfit Toys. Her only "defect" is psychological:
In the 1964 Rankin/Bass special, she reveals she considers herself a misfit because she feels unloved and abandoned. Unlike the other toys—a train with square wheels, a water pistol that shoots jelly, a bird that swims—Dolly's flaw is emotional insecurity, not a manufacturing error.
She serves as a poignant reminder that feeling unwanted can make anyone feel like a "misfit," regardless of outward perfection.