Arts >> Theater >> Musicals

Cinderella (Disney) vs. A Cinderella Story (Hilary Duff): Differences & Similarities

Key Differences

ElementDisney's Cinderella (1950/2015)A Cinderella Story (2004)
ProtagonistCinderella (Ella)Sam Montgomery
SettingFairy-tale European kingdomModern-day Los Angeles
AntagonistStepmother (Lady Tremaine) & stepsistersStepmother (Fiona) & stepsisters
Magic HelperFairy GodmotherBest friend Carter (tech-savvy)
Ball/EventRoyal ballHalloween dance / Princeton interview
TokenGlass slipperLost cell phone / rhinestone mask
EndingMarriage, "happily ever after"College together, friendship/romance implied

Core Similarities

One is fantasy; the other a modern teen rom-com adaptation. Both work because the archetype is timeless.

Musicals

Related Categories