Psy (South Korea) achieved viral global fame with “Gangnam Style” (2012)—most‑viewed YouTube video for years—but subsequent releases didn’t match that peak.
One Direction (UK/Ireland) sustained massive global popularity 2010–2016: five #1 albums, numerous hit singles, huge social media following, extensive touring, and major awards (7 Brits, 4 VMAs).
Verdict: One Direction has broader, more sustained commercial success and fanbase; Psy’s “Gangnam Style” remains a singular viral phenomenon.