How to Judge If a Title Is Appropriate: Context, Power, and Self-Identification
There is no universal checklist for title appropriateness. The answer always depends on context—historical, cultural, professional, and personal.
Key Lenses
- Cultural and Historical Baggage: Titles like "master," "chief," or "squire" can carry colonial or hierarchical weight. What was once standard may now be offensive.
- Self-Identification as Gold Standard: The most respectful approach is to use the terminology a person or group uses for themselves.
- Power Dynamics: Labels imposed by dominant groups on marginalized ones (e.g., "tribe" vs. "nation," "dialect" vs. "language") often encode inequality.
- Setting Matters: "Dr.," "Professor," "Captain" are appropriate in relevant professional contexts but may seem pretentious or irrelevant socially.
- Specificity vs. Erasure: "The disabled" (generic label) vs. "people with disabilities" (person-first language) reflects different philosophical and political stances.
Practical Steps
- Ask the person or group directly, if possible.
- Consult community-specific style guides (e.g., NAJA for Indigenous terms, GLAAD for LGBTQ+ terminology).
- When in doubt, use the person’s name.
If you have a specific title in mind, share it and I can offer a contextual analysis.