Character Count in "A Case of Identity" (Sherlock Holmes): 5–6 Core Roles
The number of characters in Conan Doyle's A Case of Identity varies by edition and definition. As a short story, its cast is deliberately small.
Core Named Characters (All Editions)
- Sherlock Holmes
- Dr. John Watson
- Mary Sutherland (client)
- James Windibank (stepfather/villain)
- Mrs. Windibank (mother, mentioned)
- Hosmer Angel (fictitious suitor—Windibank in disguise)
Peripheral/Implied
- Typist/clerks (Mary's employers)
- Gasfitters (mentioned in Holmes's deduction)
- Waiter at the restaurant (brief)
Total speaking/named roles: 5–6. The story's brilliance lies in its economy—minimal characters, maximum deduction.