Ampliative underdetermination is philosopher Larry Laudan’s argument that any body of empirical evidence can be explained by multiple, mutually incompatible scientific theories. Because theories are explanatory frameworks—not mere data summaries—the evidence never uniquely determines one theory. This challenges scientific realism: we cannot justifiably claim our best theory is “true,” only that it is currently the most effective problem-solving tool. Laudan advocates evaluating theories by their problem-solving success rather than truth-likeness.