Arts >> Theater >> Monologues

Is portayal of the commoners in act 1 Julius Caesar realistic?

In Act 1 of Julius Caesar, the commoners, also referred to as the plebeians or citizens of Rome, certainly play an important role. Their portrayal can be characterized as realistic in several aspects:

Political Influence:

The commoners are depicted as having a degree of political power. They actively engage in the political events unfolding in Rome, particularly surrounding the rise and fall of Caesar. Their support and favor are essential for any politician seeking power. This reflects the significance of the common people in the Roman political system.

Mob Mentality:

One notable feature of the commoners' portrayal is the element of mob mentality. They display emotional reactions, respond impulsively to speeches and events, and are easily swayed by powerful rhetoric. This aspect captures the reality of how large groups can be influenced by persuasive individuals, contributing to the dynamic nature of Roman politics.

Economic Hardships:

The commoners are also portrayed as facing economic hardships and disparities. They complain about their living conditions, express concerns about their families, and even express dissatisfaction with the ruling class. This reflects the social and economic realities of the Roman society, where a substantial portion of the population struggled with poverty and limited opportunities.

Devotion to Caesar:

The commoners initially display genuine devotion to Caesar. They admire his military achievements and see him as a protector of their interests. This illustrates the admiration and influence certain leaders could have on the Roman populace, demonstrating the complexities of power and loyalty in the ancient world.

Influenced by Oratory:

The portrayal of the commoners underscores the impact of oratory and persuasive speeches on their decisions and emotions. Brutus and Mark Antony both use rhetoric to sway the crowd, highlighting the pivotal role of skilled public speaking in shaping public opinion and directing the course of events.

While the portrayal of the commoners emphasizes certain traits and collective behaviors for dramatic purposes, it aligns with historical accounts of the common people's involvement and influence in Roman politics. The play depicts the commoners as essential participants in shaping the political landscape, even if their actions are influenced by emotions, loyalties, and persuasive language.

Monologues

Related Categories