Asking whether Mercutio's death is "good" misses the point—it is a structural necessity that transforms the play from romantic comedy to tragedy. Its dramatic functions:
Mercutio's death (a Montague friend killed by a Capulet) makes the conflict personal for Romeo, triggering his vengeful killing of Tybalt.
His dying curse—"A plague o' both your houses!"—condemns the senseless feud and foreshadows the final toll.
Romeo's instant, rage-driven duel with Tybalt shows the fatal flaw (hamartia) that will doom him.
Romeo's banishment separates the couple, forcing Juliet into the desperate potion plan.
The play's first half is witty, lyrical, and hopeful. After Mercutio dies, darkness, urgency, and inevitability dominate.
Mercutio's cynical, anti-romantic wit ("Queen Mab" speech) contrasts with Romeo's idealism. His death silences the play's most lucid critic of romantic delusion.
Mercutio's death is tragically necessary—it is the hinge on which the play's fate turns.